Power: A Surveyable Representation
The third session of the EPLab Permanent Seminar will be led by Robert Vinten who will talk about “Power: A Surveyable Representation”. The session will take place on 9 December at 14:30 in room A209 of NOVA FCSH (Berna Campus) and will be held in English.
Abstract
Although Wittgenstein did not concern himself much with politics his work is useful in getting clearer about the notion of power in a number of ways. In the first place, although Wittgenstein did not have much to say about power he did have quite a lot to say about ways of getting clearer about concepts and he made clarity or understanding a central aim in his philosophy. One of the ways in which he helped us to get clearer about concepts was to guide us away from the assumption that all of the items subsumed under a term must have something in common. Wittgenstein highlighted that some terms, such as “game” and “number” were family resemblance terms and it is plausible that many terms used in discussing political matters are family resemblance terms. He also reminded us of the diversity of ways in which we use language and of the fact that speech takes place within a rich weave of activities. He called these different uses of language “language games”. In analysing power it is useful to remember that discussions of power take place in many different spheres, in religion, in politics, in meteorology, chemistry, etc., and that we speak about power in many different language games. Moreover, Wittgenstein warned us against thinking that the methods of the natural sciences can be transferred straightforwardly to the social sciences and to philosophy. One of the problems with studies of power conducted in the past is that they have tried to be “scientific” by focusing on observable instances of the exercise of power. Finally, this paper will briefly look at remarks from Culture & Value where Wittgenstein does talk about power: where he distinguishes power from its bases and brings our attention to the fact that human powers are two-way powers.
Loosely based on: “Power: A Surveyable Representation”, published in the Contributions of the Austrian Ludwig Wittgenstein Society. Band / Vol. XXXI. Hrsg. von / ed. by Isabel G. Gamero, Amadeusz Just & Jasmin Trächtler in cooperation with Joseph Wang-Kathrein. Kirchberg/W.: ALWS 2025. The paper can be found here.
More information on the EPLab Permanent Seminar here.